Rev. Floyd L. Freiheit (1940 – 1941)
Rev. William R. Emerson (1941 – 1944)
Rev. Willard L. Archer (1945 -1946)
Rev. William H. Dyer (1946 – 1947)
Rev. Robert A. Howlett (1947 – 1954)
Rev. Paul R. Davis (1954 – 1963)
Rev. William Hotchkiss (1963 – 1966)
Rev. William Tice (1966 – 1970)
Rev. Melvyn Connell (1970 – 1973)
Rev. Dean Schmidt (1973 – 1974)
Rev. Ola Campbell (1974 – 1979)
Rev. James W. Doll (1979 – 1999)
Rev. Robert Solon (1999-2008)
Rev. Stephen & Laura Descalzo (2008 – 2012)
Rev. Carl N. Tenney (2012 – current)